In a recent court filing, Proton Management has disputed the allegations made by Swan Bitcoin, stating that Swan does not possess its own mining business. Instead, Proton argues that the mining operations in question are actually those of 2040 Energy, a separate entity that is fully funded by Tether.

According to the filing, 2040 Energy is not under Swan's control, despite Swan maintaining a minority stake in the business. The filing highlights the success of 2040 Energy's mining operations, attributing it to the work and ingenuity of individual defendants. Proton also notes that Swan's financial difficulties led to a significant round of layoffs in July 2024.

Following this, several key employees resigned from Swan due to concerns over the company's management and were subsequently hired by Proton to work on 2040 Energy. Proton asserts that its actions have actually enhanced the value of Swan's minority stake in 2040 Energy, rather than causing harm.

The company denies using any of Swan's alleged proprietary information or trade secrets, questioning whether such information even belongs to Swan or if it is actually owned by 2040 Energy. Proton concludes that Swan has not suffered any damage as a result of its activities and is seeking dismissal of the case, citing lack of jurisdiction due to its status as a British Virgin Islands-based company with no commercial ties to California.