With the US presidential election just a month away, two regulated platforms, Kalshi and Interactive Brokers, have launched prediction markets, allowing users to bet on the outcome. These markets are the first of their kind to be regulated in the US, with Kalshi having previously fought a lengthy legal battle with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to offer election contracts. Despite being live, the volumes on these platforms are modest, with $344,101 worth of contracts traded on Kalshi and $346,000 on Interactive Brokers' ForecastEx, compared to over $1.2 billion staked on the same race at Polymarket, a crypto-powered prediction market. According to Koleman Strumpf, an economics professor, it may be challenging for the regulated platforms to catch up, but some traders may switch from Polymarket, which has been inaccessible to US users due to a CFTC settlement.
Strumpf also noted that more than half of all trades typically occur in the month leading up to the election, providing an opportunity for the regulated platforms to gain traction. However, Polymarket has the advantage of being accessible worldwide and having no explicit position limits, which could limit the growth of the regulated markets. The prices of 'yes' shares for the candidates vary across the platforms, with Kalshi showing a 51% chance of winning for Harris and 50% for Trump, while ForecastEx shows a wider margin of 53-47 in favor of Harris.
Meanwhile, on Polymarket, the candidates are neck and neck at 49% each. Statistics professor Harry Crane stated that these differences are not significant, and the markets do not need to be identical to be useful for forecasting. Over time, observers can collect data on these markets and determine which ones have stronger predictive track records.
Kalshi had previously sued the CFTC after the agency denied its application to list contracts on which party would control each house of Congress, but the company won the case and listed the congressional contracts, which were later frozen by an appeals court. The CFTC has asked the appeals court to expedite the case, but it appears to have given up on stopping the contracts from trading before the election.