Despite Bitcoin's recent surge of nearly 15% this month, some experts remain unconvinced that the cryptocurrency has escaped the bear market that began in October, given it still lags 40% behind its record high. Some forecasters have even predicted a drastic drop to as low as $40,000, a 70% decline from its all-time peak. According to Bitcoin analyst James Check, such a drastic move, although not impossible, would be statistically extraordinary. After reaching over $126,000 in October, Bitcoin plummeted more than 50% to around $60,000 in February before stabilizing, and was trading near $78,000 on Friday.

Check argues that the predictions of the bears warrant a closer examination. Check references the Bitcoin Mean Reversion Index, a composite model that averages key valuation metrics, including the 200-week moving average and realized price. When modeled at $40,000, Bitcoin falls into the 0.4th percentile of all daily closes, which Check describes as below any meaningful deviation across major anchors. For perspective, Check notes this would be equivalent to Bitcoin trading below $2 in 2011 on a relative basis.

In contrast, today's price sits around the 31.5th percentile, historically weak but within normal correction ranges. Check emphasizes that while there's no zero probability in markets, this outcome would be nearly unprecedented.