The recent advancements in quantum computing have rekindled concerns about the potential risks to bitcoin, specifically the possibility of a powerful quantum computer breaking the elliptic curve signatures and exposing coins with visible public keys, particularly those from the early Satoshi era, as noted by bitcoin analyst James Check. However, the notion that this would lead to a market crash is not supported by the numbers.
Approximately 1.7 million BTC, valued at around $145 billion, are stored in Satoshi-era addresses that could be vulnerable to quantum computing. Although this amount seems substantial, it is, in fact, manageable. During periods of market growth, long-term holders typically distribute between 10,000 and 30,000 BTC per day. At this rate, the entire supply of Satoshi-era coins would be equivalent to about two to three months of typical profit-taking.
Furthermore, in the most recent bear market, over 2.3 million BTC changed hands in a single quarter, surpassing the potential quantum 'target' without causing a systemic collapse. Additionally, monthly exchange inflows approach 850,000 BTC, and derivatives markets cycle through notional volumes equivalent to the entire Satoshi stash every few days, demonstrating that what appears massive in isolation is relatively ordinary when set against bitcoin's existing liquidity and turnover. A sudden release of these coins would still have an impact, likely driving volatility and potentially triggering a prolonged downturn, according to Check. Nonetheless, even in this scenario, it is assumed that actors would behave irrationally.
Any entity capable of accessing such a trove would be incentivized to distribute the coins gradually, likely using derivatives to minimize losses and maximize returns. Bitcoin markets are accustomed to absorbing supply on the same order of magnitude as the P2PK era coins, with the timeframe measured in months rather than years.
The real issue at hand is not the mechanical sell pressure, but rather governance, specifically the potential freezing of Satoshi coins through BIP-361, and allowing the situation to unfold naturally.