According to Jameson Lopp, a prominent Bitcoin core developer, it would be preferable to freeze the estimated 5.6 million lost or dormant bitcoin rather than risking them being compromised by future quantum hackers. Lopp emphasized that he does not wish to freeze anyone's bitcoin but believes removing these tokens from circulation could be safer for the network. He stated, 'At the moment, I don't believe any of this is necessary,' and is instead thinking ahead to potential future threats.
Lopp's comments follow the release of BIP-361, a proposal that explores phasing out Bitcoin's current cryptographic signatures and potentially freezing assets that fail to migrate. The dormant tokens in question are valued at approximately $420 billion at current prices.
Lopp expressed his dislike for the proposal, describing it as a 'rough idea for a contingency plan' rather than a finalized specification, and hopes it will never need to be implemented. He believes that individual economic incentives outweigh philosophical principles in the face of an existential threat. Lopp has previously expressed concerns about quantum recovery, which he views as rewarding technological supremacy over productive participation in the network. Approximately 28% of all bitcoin, or around 5.6 million tokens, has not moved in over a decade and is considered likely lost.
If these coins were to be recovered through advances in quantum computing, it could introduce significant volatility and undermine confidence in the original cryptocurrency network. The proposal has sparked intense debate within the community, with some arguing that freezing dormant bitcoin accounts would mark a significant departure from Bitcoin's core principles. Market analyst Mati Greenspan noted that the debate is more philosophical than technological, and that freezing dormant coins could remove a major tail-risk and protect market confidence, but also introduces a precedent of intervention that many argue is more dangerous than the threat itself.
Others, such as Leo Fan, argue that freezing dormant BTC accounts risks undermining Bitcoin's foundational guarantees, as ownership becomes conditional and having keys no longer guarantees the ability to spend.