The unexpected performance of bitcoin during the Iran conflict has prompted a reassessment of its value proposition. Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan suggests that bitcoin's 12% gain since the start of the conflict, despite the S&P 500's 1% decline and gold's 10% drop, signals a shift in the market's perception of its role. Hougan proposes that bitcoin represents two concurrent bets: the 'digital gold' thesis, where it competes for a share of the $38 trillion store-of-value market, and an 'out-of-the-money call option' on its potential to function as a genuine currency.
The Iran conflict has altered the dynamics of the latter bet, with the country's decision to collect a bitcoin toll from ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz marking a significant example of a sovereign state utilizing bitcoin for physical commerce. This development has increased the probability of bitcoin being used as a currency while boosting the volatility of the global monetary system, thereby enhancing the value of this 'call option.' If this framework holds, it could imply that bitcoin will experience rallies during future geopolitical conflicts, particularly those involving countries caught between the US and Chinese financial systems, and that its total addressable market may be larger than the gold market alone.
However, skeptics argue that Iran's use of bitcoin is driven by necessity rather than preference, highlighting the limitations of dollar-denominated enforcement rather than bitcoin's readiness as a neutral settlement layer. Nevertheless, Hougan's observation that the market is pricing bitcoin differently during this conflict than in previous geopolitical shocks remains valid, and the 'digital gold' thesis alone cannot fully explain this phenomenon.