According to Jameson Lopp, a prominent Bitcoin core developer, it would be preferable to freeze approximately 5.6 million lost or dormant bitcoin rather than risk them being compromised by future quantum hackers. Lopp emphasized that his primary concern is the potential threat posed by quantum computing, which could potentially allow attackers to access dormant coins, thereby destabilizing the network. Although Lopp expressed reluctance to freeze any bitcoin, he believes that removing dormant tokens from circulation might be a necessary precaution to safeguard the network. The estimated value of these dormant tokens is around $420 billion at current prices.
Lopp's comments come in response to the recent release of BIP-361, a proposal aimed at phasing out Bitcoin's current cryptographic signatures and rendering transactions from quantum-vulnerable wallets invalid over time. This proposal has sparked intense debate within the Bitcoin community, with some arguing that it would be a departure from the fundamental principles of the cryptocurrency. Market analyst Mati Greenspan noted that the debate surrounding the freezing of dormant bitcoin accounts is more philosophical than technological, as it raises questions about the balance between security and the core principles of Bitcoin.
Others, such as Leo Fan, argue that freezing dormant accounts could undermine Bitcoin's promise of 'unstoppable money' and introduce conditional ownership. The proposal has ignited a fierce discussion about the best course of action to protect the network from potential quantum threats, with some advocating for the freezing of dormant coins and others opposing it on philosophical grounds.