Notably, beneath the daily price fluctuations, social media posts, and macroeconomic headlines, a remarkably straightforward indicator has consistently predicted every major market bottom since 2015. Unfortunately for bulls, this indicator has not been triggered yet, implying that the broader bear market may not be over and the recent price surge to $75,000 from $65,000 could be a short-term recovery. The indicator in question involves two lines on the price chart, representing bitcoin's average price over the past 50 and 100 weeks, acting as simple moving averages that illustrate near-term and long-term trends in bitcoin's price.
Typically, the 50-week average is above the 100-week line, which is the natural state for markets that trend upward over time, as is the case with bitcoin. However, during periods of intense fear, relentless selling, and collapsed sentiment, the 50-week average falls below the 100-week average, resulting in a bear market signal. This crossover has occurred three times in bitcoin's history, each time coinciding with the end of a bear market and marking major price bottoms that have not been revisited since, serving as a contrary indicator that ironically marks bottoms rather than deeper downturns.
Looking at the vertical lines on the chart dating back to 2015, these mark the three bearish crossovers – April 2015, February 2019, and September 2022 – each occurring near the bottoming phase, not precisely at the lowest point, but within the same range. In 2015, BTC was written off as a failed experiment, but after the crossover happened, BTC subsequently rallied from $200 to nearly $20,000 by the end of 2017. A similar pattern played out after the early 2019 crossover. The 2022 crypto winter, characterized by several bankruptcies and scams, shattered investor confidence, but the downtrend lost momentum after the crossover occurred in September, and BTC bottomed out in the final months, later rallying to $126,000 by October 2020.
Each of these bull runs delivered returns far exceeding those of equities and other major asset classes. As of April 17, the crossover has not happened, with bitcoin declining sharply from its October record high of over $126,000 to around $75,000, briefly reaching $60,000 in early February.
Consequently, the two averages are moving closer together, but the 50-week average still holds above the 100-week average. The key takeaway is that if history is any guide, the broader bear market may still be intact and could worsen before finding a bottom, also implying that the recent bounce toward $75,000 is likely a temporary recovery rather than the start of a full-fledged bull market. Nevertheless, historical patterns are just that – patterns – and they do not guarantee future outcomes, especially considering that if U.S. equities, already at record highs, continue to advance, institutional demand for Bitcoin ETFs could strengthen, potentially supporting a price rally.