The recent performance of bitcoin, which has gained 12% since the start of the Iran conflict, defies conventional wisdom, prompting Bitwise CIO Matt Hougan to offer an alternative explanation. With bitcoin's value reaching $75,050.37, its outperformance during this period is notable, especially when compared to the 1% decline in the S&P 500 and the 10% drop in gold. Hougan suggests that bitcoin can be viewed as two simultaneous bets: the 'digital gold' thesis, where it competes for a share of the $38 trillion store-of-value market, and an 'out-of-the-money call option' on bitcoin functioning as a legitimate currency.

The Iran conflict has altered the dynamics of the second bet, as the country's decision to collect a $1-per-barrel toll in bitcoin from ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz marks one of the first instances of a sovereign state using bitcoin as a settlement mechanism for physical commerce. This development has increased the odds of bitcoin being used as a currency while also boosting the volatility of the global monetary order, making the argument worth considering.

If Hougan's framework holds, it would imply that bitcoin should experience a rally during future geopolitical conflicts, particularly those involving countries caught between the US and Chinese financial systems, and that its total addressable market is significantly larger than the gold market alone. However, the counterpoint is that Iran's use of bitcoin is driven by necessity rather than preference, highlighting the limitations of dollar-denominated enforcement rather than bitcoin's readiness to function as a neutral settlement layer.

Nevertheless, Hougan's core observation remains valid, as the market is pricing bitcoin differently during this conflict than during any prior geopolitical shock, and the 'digital gold' thesis alone cannot explain this phenomenon.