A recent study by Charles Schwab on digital assets suggests that the role of cryptocurrencies in a portfolio is more closely tied to an investor's risk appetite than potential returns. The report highlights bitcoin and ether as high-volatility assets that can rapidly alter a portfolio's risk profile, noting that any investment in cryptocurrency is likely to increase a portfolio's overall volatility.

Historical data shows that both bitcoin and ether have experienced significant drawdowns of over 70% in the past, far exceeding typical declines seen in stocks or bonds. As a result, even small allocations to cryptocurrency can have a disproportionate impact on a portfolio's risk.

According to Schwab, allocations as low as 1% to 3% can substantially change how a portfolio behaves during times of market stress. The report outlines two common methods for adding cryptocurrency exposure to a portfolio. The first approach, based on traditional portfolio theory, takes into account expected returns, volatility, and correlations.

However, Schwab notes that this method is limited by the wide range of assumptions about cryptocurrency returns among investors. The report states that if expected returns are less than 10%, even for aggressive investors, cryptocurrencies may not offer a sufficiently high risk-adjusted return to justify a significant allocation.

This makes portfolio outcomes highly sensitive to subjective forecasts, with small changes in expected returns potentially leading to large swings in recommended allocations. The second approach focuses on risk budgeting, where investors determine how much of their total portfolio risk they want to attribute to cryptocurrency, rather than trying to predict returns. This method shifts the focus from performance to risk tolerance. However, Schwab warns that the volatility of cryptocurrencies can exceed expectations, even within a defined risk budget.

The report concludes that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to allocating cryptocurrency in a portfolio, and the decision is largely a personal one, influenced by factors such as investment horizon, familiarity with digital assets, and capacity for loss. Additionally, the firm emphasizes that cryptocurrency remains a speculative investment, carrying risks such as illiquidity, theft, and fraud, and is not suitable for all investors.