Circle Internet Financial CEO Jeremy Allaire has provided his most direct response to criticism over the company's handling of illicit funds, stating that it only freezes wallets when there is a formal legal basis to do so. Speaking at a press conference in Seoul, Allaire emphasized that USDC, the second-largest dollar-pegged stablecoin, operates as a regulated financial product rather than a tool for immediate intervention.

Allaire highlighted that Circle has a clear obligation to perform under the law and follows the rule of law, undertaking actions such as freezing wallets only at the direction of law enforcement or the courts. He positioned USDC as part of the traditional financial system, subject to legal processes and oversight, suggesting that decisions to blacklist or freeze funds should be made following requests from law enforcement or court orders, rather than at the company's discretion.

This approach aligns with Circle's strategy to work closely with regulators and institutions. In contrast, Tether, the issuer of the world's largest stablecoin, USDT, has a more proactive approach, frequently freezing funds linked to hacks and illicit activity within hours.

Allaire's comments come at a time of increasing scrutiny, following a suspected North Korea-linked exploit of Drift Protocol that resulted in losses of up to $280 million, with roughly $230 million in USDC moved across chains over several hours. Critics argue that Circle's inaction has contributed to over $420 million in illicit funds escaping, pointing to multiple incidents where stolen USDC remained in identifiable wallets for hours or days without being frozen. However, others in the industry caution that faster intervention carries its own risks, potentially undermining the foundations of decentralized finance (DeFi) by introducing centralized points of control.

Omid Malekan, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, warned that allowing issuers to act beyond legal requirements could erode trust in DeFi systems, stating that such powers could lead to a situation where 'code is not law, but also law is not law,' and instead, what a single executive decides becomes law.