A recent study by Charles Schwab on digital assets highlights that the inclusion of cryptocurrencies in a portfolio is more closely tied to an investor's risk tolerance than to potential returns. The report categorizes bitcoin and ether as high-volatility assets capable of rapidly changing a portfolio's risk profile.

It notes that any allocation to cryptocurrency is likely to increase a portfolio's volatility, given the sharp historical price swings of these assets, including declines of over 70% in previous cycles, which exceed typical declines in stocks or bonds. Due to this volatility, even minimal allocations can have a significant impact. According to Schwab, a crypto allocation as low as 1% to 3% can substantially alter a portfolio's behavior during times of market stress.

The report identifies two common methods for adding crypto exposure to a portfolio. The first approach, based on traditional portfolio theory, considers expected returns, volatility, and correlations. However, Schwab points out a key limitation: investors' assumptions about crypto returns vary widely. The report states that if return expectations are less than 10%, even for an aggressive investor, cryptocurrencies may not offer a sufficient risk-adjusted return to justify a significant allocation.

This makes portfolio outcomes highly sensitive to subjective forecasts, where a modest change in expected returns can lead to large changes in recommended allocation. The second approach focuses on risk budgeting, where investors decide how much of the total portfolio risk they want crypto to contribute, shifting the focus from performance to risk tolerance.

Nonetheless, Schwab cautions that crypto's volatility can exceed expectations, even within a defined risk budget. The report emphasizes that there is no one-size-fits-all allocation to cryptocurrencies, believing the decision to be largely personal and influenced by factors such as investment horizon, familiarity with digital assets, and capacity for loss. Furthermore, the firm stresses that crypto remains a speculative investment, citing risks such as illiquidity, theft, and fraud, and suggesting it can offer diversification and potential for higher returns but behaves more like a high-risk satellite holding than a core allocation.