A high-profile US enforcement case is once again highlighting the issue of wash trading and the fine line between market makers and manipulators. Federal prosecutors in California have charged 10 individuals linked to companies such as Gotbit, Vortex, Antier, and Contrarian, accusing them of orchestrating trades to artificially inflate token prices and volumes before selling into the fabricated demand.
The case originated from an undercover FBI operation where agents created their own token to identify firms offering manipulation services. The defendants promoted strategies that essentially amounted to pump-and-dump schemes and wash trading, leaving behind evidence that suggests this practice is more widespread than expected, according to crypto experts Jason Fernandes from AdLunam and Stefan Muehlbauer from Certik. 'Despite increased regulatory efforts, wash trading remains a pervasive issue, particularly among lower-cap tokens and on unregulated exchanges,' Muehlbauer stated, while Fernandes noted that 'it's far more common than most investors realize.' Gotbit Founder Aleksei Andriunin, who was included in the recent Department of Justice indictments, pleaded guilty to two counts of wire fraud and conspiracy to commit market manipulation last year and agreed to forfeit $23 million.
US prosecutors described his crimes as a 'wide-ranging conspiracy' to manipulate token prices for paying clients. The practice of inflating volumes has become a shortcut to relevance in the crypto space. 'Wash trading exists because, in crypto, liquidity is perception,' said Jason Fernandes, co-founder of AdLunam. 'Volume attracts attention, listings, and capital, so inflating it becomes a shortcut to relevance.' The mechanics of wash trading are straightforward: coordinated accounts trade back and forth to simulate demand, often outsourced to market makers who are paid to create the illusion of organic flow.
This practice is far more common than investors believe or expect, particularly in long-tail tokens and on smaller exchanges where oversight is limited, Fernandes added. 'In many cases, it's not just rogue actors; it's projects, market-making firms, and even venues themselves, all benefiting from higher reported volume.' The DOJ stated that the firms included in their indictment used coordinated trading to inflate volumes and prices, ultimately selling tokens at artificially high levels to unsuspecting investors.
Recent research has repeatedly pointed to inflated activity across crypto markets. A Columbia University analysis of Polymarket found that roughly 25% of historical volume showed signs of wash trading, while earlier Dune Analytics data suggested that tens of billions in NFT volume on Ethereum stemmed from similar activity. Wash trading remains a 'pervasive issue,' according to Certik. 'The recent actions by the US Department of Justice send a clear signal,' said Stefan Muehlbauer, head of US government affairs at CertiK.
'The 'wild west' era of crypto market manipulation is facing a coordinated, global crackdown. While these indictments represent a major victory for market integrity, wash trading remains a significant concern.' Despite years of scrutiny, the incentives behind this practice remain intact, he said. Token issuers often face pressure to meet exchange listing requirements tied to trading volume, leading some to turn to market makers to simulate activity or deploy bots that trade against themselves.
'The 'why' is simple: illusion of value,' Muehlbauer said. 'That illusion has real consequences,' particularly because artificial volume distorts price discovery, masks weak liquidity, and can funnel capital based on signals that are not real. 'High volume signals to investors and exchanges that a token is hot and liquid.' 'Victims are investors relying on that liquidity and high volume data,' Fernandes said.
'Wash trading distorts markets, leading to “mispriced risk and capital flowing based on signals that aren’t real.” The latest DOJ case may bring a glimmer of hope to the industry. 'What’s notable isn’t just the charge but the method,' Fernandes said.
'When the FBI is creating tokens to catch market manipulation, you’re no longer in a grey area. This is the US signaling that crypto market structure is now firmly in enforcement territory.' For market participants, the line between legitimate liquidity provision and manipulation is coming under sharper scrutiny, said the AdLunam co-founder. Efforts to detect and reduce wash trading are improving.
Regulated exchanges are deploying more sophisticated surveillance tools, while analysts are increasingly looking beyond headline volume to metrics such as order book depth, slippage, and counterparty diversity. Enforcement may ultimately push the market forward, although for now, the DOJ case has shed light on just how pervasive wash trading continues to be, undermining trust in crypto markets. 'Crypto is moving from a loosely policed frontier market to something that has to withstand institutional scrutiny.
An irony is that enforcement like this may ultimately strengthen the asset class,' Fernandes said. In Muehlbauer’s words, 'the message to the industry is clear: what was once brushed off as ‘market making’ is now being prosecuted as wire fraud and market manipulation.'